Loading today's hours...
Everything Made From Scratch
Milroy OIP – Original Italian Pizza has been serving authentic, handcrafted favorites for over 30 years. Enjoy hand-tossed pizzas, subs made on our house-baked rolls, and fresh homemade bread baked every hour. We're a true neighborhood kitchen where quality and tradition come first. Fresh, friendly, and fantastic, every single day.
Pizzas You Won't Find Anywhere Else
Dill Pickle Pizza, Mac Daddy, Hoagie Pizza, HEAVY DUTY Sicilian — these are what happen when a kitchen knows its regulars and isn't afraid to have fun.
Subs on Homemade Rolls
Every sub comes on a roll baked right here. Meatball parm, Original Italian, Chicken Cordon Bleu, made the way they're supposed to be. Call (717) 667-3711 and we'll have yours ready.
From The Kitchen
From The Oven
Made From Scratch in Milroy
Family-owned along Old US Highway 322 in Milroy, PA — fresh dough every morning, bread baking every hour, every pizza hand-tossed with real LOVE.
What our guests are saying
Catered for our rehearsal dinner. Pizza and salad were great, and the service was even better!
Calen S.
Very good Italian food. They had a Tuesday lunch special for two single topping slices with a soda. We had the medium Stromboli to share with two people and it was huge but it was really good. We also had the Italian hoagie, and got fries to share which were nice and crispy. Good food for the price!
Zoe G.
Great pizza and extremely friendly staff!
AWA
Milroy OIP - Original Italian Pizza Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Visit Us Today
Stop by Milroy OIP - Original Italian Pizza and enjoy fresh, made-from-scratch pizzas, homemade rolls, hearty subs, and Italian favorites served with friendly hometown hospitality. Fresh, friendly, fantastic, that's the promise on every order. Whether you're dining in, picking up dinner, or ordering for the family, we're ready to serve your favorite meal.
Visit us at 5037 Old US Hwy 322
Reedsville, PA 17084 or call (717) 667-3711 to place your order today. We look forward to welcoming you! 🍕
Catering & Events
Bring the flavors of Milroy OIP - Original Italian Pizza to your next gathering. From family celebrations and office lunches to community events and special occasions, our crowd-pleasing pizzas, subs, salads, and Italian favorites make feeding a group easy. Call (717) 667-3711 to plan your order.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Meatballs, Wings, Pizza Slice, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Greek Salad, Calzone, Pan Pizza, Spaghetti, Ravioli, Salads, Lasagna, Chicken Alfredo, Caesar Salad, Pizza by the Slice, Mozzarella Sticks, Stromboli, Hoagies, Grilled Chicken Salad, Cannoli, Pasta, Supreme Pizza, Veggie Pizza, Greek Pizza, Meat Lovers Pizza, Hand Tossed Pizza, Subs, and Italian Subs
Where are you located?
We are located in Reedsville, PA at 5037 Old US Hwy 322
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Church Hill, Roseann, Milroy, Woodland, Honey Creek, Shrader, Potlicker Flats, Naginey, Reedsville, Brown, Lumber City, Knobville, Locke Mills, Cedar Hill, Siglerville, Yeagertown, Vira, Burnham, Derry, and Barrville.
Our location
